Surgeons are less likely than family physicians or patients to view
surgery as the preferred treatment option for low back pain, according
to a study in the January 1 issue of Spine.
Quality of Life Issues
For patients with back
pain, quality-of-life issues are the main factor affecting treatment
preferences--which has important implications for shared decision-making
between patients and their doctors, according to the new study led by
Dr. S. Samuel Bederman at University of Toronto.
Family Doctors Have Highest Preferences for Surgery
The
researchers presented hypothetical back pain scenarios to surgeons
(orthopedic surgeons and neurosurgeons), family physicians, and
patients with back and/or leg pain. The scenarios reflected key factors
related to back pain:
- walking ability
- pain duration
- pain severity
- neurological symptoms
- factors inducing pain
- pain location
Each
group rated their preference for surgery in each scenario, and the
factors affecting preferences were analyzed.
Perhaps
unexpectedly, surgeons had the lowest overall preferences for surgery,
while family physicians had the highest preference for surgery.
- For
orthopedic surgeons, the preference for surgery was somewhat lower than
for neurosurgeons.
- Both the family doctors and patients had a higher
preference for surgery than either group of surgeons.
The factors
affecting preferences for surgery varied as well.
Location of Back and Leg Pain
For surgeons, the
most important factor was the location of pain. In particular, they
preferred surgery for patients with pain predominantly in the leg,
rather than the back. Surgery provides better results in patients with
problems affecting the spinal nerve roots, which tend to cause leg pain.
Family Physician Preferences for Surgery
In
contrast, for family physicians, the most important factor affecting
preferences for surgery was neurological symptoms, followed closely by
walking ability and pain severity.
Family doctors may be unaware of
which factors affect the chances of good outcomes from back surgery,
the researchers suggest.
Top Back Pain Patient Concerns
For patients, the most important factors
were pain severity, walking ability, and pain duration. "All of these
symptoms are highly related to quality of life and have little direct
bearing on outcomes following surgery," Dr. Bederman and co-authors
write.
Successful Pack Surgery
When other treatments have failed, surgery can help
patients with moderate to severe lower back pain. Family physicians
play an important role in sending back pain patients for surgical
evaluation. However, few studies looked at the factors considered by
primary care doctors consider in referring patients for possible spinal
surgery. The final decision is generally made through a shared process
between the patient, family physician, and surgeon.
Key Metric for Surgery Solutions for Back Pain
The new
results suggest that, in various scenarios, surgeons have a lower
preference for surgery than family physicians. In addition, the factors
that surgeons feel are most important--especially the location of
pain--don't match those considered most important by family doctors.
Importance of Quality of Life Factors
The
study also highlights the importance of quality-of-life
factors--especially pain severity and duration and walking ability--in
affecting patients' treatment preferences.
Dr. Bederman and colleagues
hope their findings will help in "aligning" the opinions of patients
and doctors, thus improving the shared decision-making process and
promoting more accurate patient expectations of the results of surgery.
"This can directly result in a significant improvement in patient
satisfaction with the healthcare process and even overall health status
following treatment," the researchers write.
About Spine
Spine
is an international, peer-reviewed, bi-weekly periodical that considers
for publication original articles in the field of spine. It is the
leading subspecialty journal for the treatment of spinal disorders.
According to the latest ISI Science Citation Impact Factor, Spine ranks highest among subspecialty orthopedic titles. Visit the journal website at www.spinejournal.com